Tuesday, January 10, 2017

A critic of the "cultural appropriation" nonsense

Novelist Lionel Shriver:

‘I don’t feel this way about everything I think, but to me, in this case, my perspective is so self-evidently true, that it’s not even worth having the discussion.’ She’s talking about the source of her recent infamy, the run-in with the right-on crowd, following her criticism of cultural appropriation, the idea that one shouldn’t use or adopt elements of another culture different to one’s own.

Sitting in her kitchen, she defends her argument: ‘Fiction writing is a form of pillaging, happy pillaging, theft that doesn’t hurt anybody or take anything away from people. I saw on the news recently that Edna O’Brien is writing a book, set in Nigeria, which has a lot to do with Boko Haram’s kidnapping of the school girls. If that’s cultural appropriation, then good luck to her. Doesn’t it express an interest in other people’s problems? And one that she doesn’t really have to indulge? She could just keep setting books in Ireland. Isn’t it admirable that she has an eye on the wider world? And I would say that it’s admirable even if she falls flat on her face. I admire that impulse, getting outside your tiny garden.’

When Shriver spoke out against cultural appropriation at ‘a rather modest out-of-the-way literary festival’ in Brisbane, Australia, her contention that fiction is necessarily inauthentic, and that writers ought to be free to write about characters from a range of cultural backgrounds, initially met little resistance.

It was only when a young activist walked out of Shriver’s talk, later describing it as a ‘poisoned package wrapped up in arrogance’, that Shriver’s comments suddenly became controversial. Since then, she says she has ‘got it in the neck for somehow not presenting my case the way I was supposed to’.

But this doesn’t bother her in the slightest. ‘For the sake of sheer variety, someone needs to get a different perspective out’, she tells me defiantly. ‘Fiction writing is a form of pillaging, happy pillaging, theft that doesn’t hurt anybody or take anything away from people’



Anonymous said...

a young activist walked out of Shriver’s talk

Young activists think they are terribly sophisticated, but mostly they are just young idiots who have absorbed too much Liberal nonsense.

Bird of Paradise said...

Liberals spout off liberal nonsense just listen to some bunch of anti fracking anti drilling keep it in the ground activists their always spouting out liberal nonsense every time their open their big fat pieholes

Anonymous said...

If you pit BoP against a turnip in a battle of wits, the turnip wins every time.

Bird of Paradise said...

Anon 4:50 Go and inhale your brains you pinhead

Anonymous said...

BoP, is that all you got? You are even pathetic at insult throwing. LMFAO.

Anonymous said...

It is interesting that ALL cultures appropriate things from other cultures to grow and remain vibrant but now the "progressives" want to stop that process. That is true irony but then "progressives" are not open to any ideas but their own.