Saturday, April 05, 2008

Hatred and bigotry from an "opponent" of hatred and bigotry

So what else is new?

I recently received a letter commenting adversely on one of my posts on SOCIALIZED MEDICINE. The post was headed "Another useless (Sorry: "underqualified") Muslim doctor in Britain". The writer took umbrage at that heading. He evidently felt that I was defaming Muslim doctors generally or perhaps Muslims generally. Where have I heard that sort of accusation before? You can say anything you like about Christians and conservatives but some classes of people -- such as Muslims and homosexuals -- are especially protected from criticism.

And that is bigotry. Closing your mind to certain possibilities is a good rough definition of bigotry and my correspondent has clearly closed his mind to the possibility of any general defect among Muslim doctors.

I do in fact suspect that doctors from Muslim countries are in general of lower quality but I don't know that and I have never asserted that. All my post conveyed was that there are some Muslim doctors of lower quality. "Some" could be a small minority and maybe it is a small minority that is involved. I was at most suggesting the hypothesis that the effect might be general. And why should that hypothesis not be suggested? Only a bigot rules out hypotheses in advance.

I reproduce the rapidly deteriorating correspondence concerned below. I give my replies in italics. I kinda feel sorry for the guy. He is so used to having his prejudices celebrated that he is unable to see that they are prejudices.

Dr. Ray,

We look to your web site often as a valuable pointer to information. But your reference to the religion of an incompetent doctor does your site no credit, and it doesn't help the cause of reducing errors. Aside from its irrelevance, do you know of some evidence that doctors who come from predominately Muslim countries commit more errors that doctors trained in the UK? Where in your linked article does it say that he is Muslim? Where does it say that he isn't a native Brit, or mention anything about this religion.

Are you planning to include a mentions from now on like "Another useless Christian doctor botches procedure," Or "Again a Jewish doctor kills a patient"?

Nicolas Martin [aia@iatrogenic.org]
Executive Director
American Iatrogenic Association

There have been some awful Muslim doctors recently so I think "another" is warranted.

His name is a Muslim one

I oppose political correctness
JR


There is a difference between PC and simply being civil. I have had plenty of Arab Christian acquaintances who had what you think is a "Muslim" name. If you really oppose political correctness, then I'll look for that headline that says "Another useless Christian doctor botches a surgery." Now that would be un-PC. As it presently stands, I can't think of anything more PC than to be anti-Muslim. How much guts does it take to libel Muslims? None.

Like I said, you have provided no evidence that Muslim doctors commit more errors that non-Muslim ones, so your objective is more to defame them than to shine a light on the facts. Since there are many Muslim doctors one would hope that you would want them to be oppose socialized medicine, too. And some of them maybe be very receptive to the free market message. But maybe hate is more important to you than freedom.

Nicolas Martin

"Another" does not mean "all". I made no claim about Muslims in general. I just describe reality as I see it. You are reading into what I wrote things that I did not say. Perhaps you should examine your own biases.

JR


That's a joke, right? Then, as I said, I look forward to reading about the religion of all the doctors you mention. You describe reality as a bigot sees it. I'll make damned sure that we don't refer to your site again.

Nicolas Martin

Bigot!

JR

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Wasn't the Muslim driver of the Jeep that crashed and burned at Heaththrow (or was it Gatwick) a doctor?

Anonymous said...

Wow John. Did this guy nail you or what?

His point is perfectly correct.

You labeled the guy as a Muslim doctor despite your post and supporting article not supporting the claim of his religion. In fact, you only claim that he is Muslim because of his name.

You have no supporting evidence of your claim.

You have a right to say what you want in your blogs but when people call you on the claims you make as being unsubstantiated, try not to whine and cry like a little baby.

Of course, you have the right to do that as well. It is just unseemly and childish.

Anonymous said...

It was a Muslim name? How do you know the religion of someone by name, "Dr Ray"? . I have a big nose? Am I Jewish. I have a large penis. Am I black?

Anonymous said...

"It was a Muslim name? How do you know the religion of someone by name, "Dr Ray"? . I have a big nose? Am I Jewish. I have a large penis. Am I black?"

Let me guess! Your name is Martin Luther King-Goldstein, right?