Wednesday, April 11, 2012


John Derbyshire is not backing down

Below is an excerpt from his response to the furore over his advice that whites should avoid blacks
The natural preference most people have for some races—usually their own—over others means that multiracial societies are plagued with stresses that you don't see in monoracial societies. The tendency in modern times is to separation. Look at residential and educational patterns in the U.S.A. I discuss these issues at length in my book We Are Doomed.

A friend of mine who is an academic social scientist likes to say that if you want to know what people believe, there are two methods of inquiry: (A) ask them, or (B) observe their behavior. It's a depressing fact about human nature that if you apply both (A) and (B) to a given situation, the answers you get will not necessarily be the same. Whether we are, as our current Attorney General said, a nation of cowards about race, I don't know; but looking at those residential and educational patterns, it's awfully hard to deny that we are a nation of liars.

The big question is whether these problems, as they manifest themselves in the U.S.A., are solvable. Current orthodoxy is that they are, and offers a laundry list of solution methods. Fix the schools! End poverty! Stamp out racism! Affirmative action! Fifty years ago a thoughtful person could sign on to those prescriptions. I know: I was around: I did. Yes (we said) once unjust laws had been struck down, and some social massaging of that sort been done for a few years, the races would merge in happy harmony, and the word "race" and its derivatives would drop out of the language. We all believed that. I believed it.

Plainly this hasn't happened, except of course in the upper classes, which go by their own rules. For a thoughtful person today to believe that these social-engineering nostrums will (for example) bring black crime rates to a level indistinguishable from white crime rates, involves a strenuous act of what Orwell called "doublethink"—massive self-deception. Does anyone, after all those decades, all those trillions of dollars, all those failed social-engineering experiments, does anyone really, honestly still believe in the nostrums? I don't.

My own sense of the thing is that underneath the happy talk, underneath the dogged adherence to failed ideas and dead theories, underneath the shrieking and anathematizing at people like me, there is a deep and cold despair. In our innermost hearts,we don't believe racial harmony can be attained. Hence the trend to separation. We just want to get on with our lives away from each other. Yet for a moralistic, optimistic people like Americans, this despair is unbearable. It's pushed away somewhere we don't have to think about it. When someone forces us to think about it, we react with fury. That little boy in the Andersen story about the Emperor's new clothes? The ending would be more true to life if he had been lynched by a howling mob of outraged citizens.

Source

Derbyshire is ill with leukemia so may not have long to live.  So I guess he feels that he has nothing to lose by calling it like it is.  Sad that it takes a dying man to point out the obvious.

I note that elsewhere  in the article Derb says that he is fine with Asians.  I am too.  I have several Indians living with me in my house.  They are  gentlemen as far as I am concerned.  Who cares if they are brown?  What a racist I must be!


4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Florida Marlins' manager suspended for 5 games because he said he respected Fidel Castro.

http://www.channel3000.com/sports/Marlins-suspend-manager-Guillen-for-five-games/-/1612/10398514/-/dc3ty0z/-/

Anonymous said...

Interesting, antisemites can draw swastikas in maple syrup on jewish homes and not get charged with hate crimes in California.

http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/lookout/comedian-jon-lovitz-says-anti-semitic-prank-no-210812430.html

Anonymous said...

I believe most people really are not all that concerned with the color of a person's skin. They are concerned about being assaulted. When a certain group tend to do most of the assaulting, people do not want to be around them. Its as simple as that.

Anonymous said...

Unless it kills you first!