Monday, August 20, 2012



Should Russian feminist punks have been jailed?

Even after 70 years of Communism, Russia is a very religious place,  so it attracted a lot of attention when a punk band called  "Pussy Riot" invaded Moscow's main cathedral, mounted one of the holiest places in it, and performed an obscene  song critical of the Russian Orthodox church and of Vladimir Putin, Russia's prime minister at the time.  Words of the "song" are here.

This was very disturbing to worshippers who were present and security guards promptly grabbed the band members and hustled them away. 

The performers  were arrested and charged with “hooliganism motivated by religious hatred” and got 2 years' jail, which in Russia probably MEANS 2 years' jail.

There have been many expressions of support for the band in the Western world but much of that is probably motivated by a dislike of Mr Putin, who is undoubtedly something of a tyrant.  Even more unforgiveable (to the Left) he is also a patriotic Christian who attends church regularly

What would have happened if the band had done something similar in a mosque?  In Pakistan they would be dead now;  In Britain they would be in prison and in the USA they would probably have been given some small penalty for "trespass" or the like.

If Muslims are entitled to respect for their holy places, it seems to me that Russian Orthodox people should have similar rights.  I see the matter as not about speech but about behaviour and that is indeed how the Russian  prosecutors charged them.

When people are allowed to invade mosques and put on performances  offensive to the worshippers, then I will see the prison sentences in this matter as excessive.

British Libertarian writer Sean Gabb argues that the sentence is not excessive.


9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Sure, they were offensive and trespassed, but I think it was more of a stunt and I haven't heard of any actual damage. Two years in a Russian prison should seem excessive for anybody who isn't a statist.

Menoichius said...

I think it should have been some sort of fine. They were trespassing on what I'm assuming is private property (or as private as anything can be over there), but jail definitely seems excessive.

Anonymous said...

In Russia today to be noticed internationally (as it has), it probably had to be some very media-attracting demo against the totalitarianism of Putin, who is getting himself dubiously re-elected to potentially permanent leader by playing "musical-chairs" with his appointed prime-minister. The Russian Orthodox Church is also in the pocket of Putin, just as it was with the Czar (and as the established churches were/are in other european countries).

Anonymous said...

... meaning in the pocket of the political establishment of their respective countries.

Anonymous said...

Usually Christians are more forgiving than that. From what I read in other news articles, this church has tight bonds to Putin, which is why the girls struck there. This is more about politics than religion.

JR said...

I think if you see it from a Russian perspective, the sentence was light

They seem in general to be a very punitive lot

Anonymous said...

It would probably have been a much longer sentence if the case hadn't attracted such global exposure.

Why ? said...

While we're all on a Pussy Riot, a real political prisoner exists in one Brendon O'Connell who resides in a West Australian prison for publicly opposing the Zionist activism of those who more than likely support the Pussy Rioters.

Crucified for the tenor of his speech, O'Connell is too a disciple of Christ, but rarely a Godly Word in his defense is uttered by those who also follow Christ.

Why ?

Anonymous said...

http://rt.com/news/femen-cross-pussy-riot-930/

More public vandalism by the "pussy riot". Like most media theatrics, all this Shit is contrived.

It happened in Russia before post Bolshevic revolution. Quietly, it is developing in the United States.