Monday, June 18, 2007

American Court Overturns Restrictive British Libel Judgment

British libel laws make it very difficult to expose corruption, political or otherwise. If you accuse anybody of dishonesty or corruption, you can be sued, of course. But to defend yourself in Britain you then have to become the equivalent of an official prosecutor and prove your case fully against the corrupt person. You have to become the equivalent of a team of detectives and a prosecutor all rolled up into one.

That is so difficult that free speech about dishonesty and corruption is impossible in Britain for anybody except the media -- who have recently won an exemption from the laws concerned.

In American law, by contrast, the onus is on the person "libelled" to prove that the allegations about him are untrue. The American system gives primacy to protecting free speech, in accordance with the First Amendment.

So when a Saudi financier of terrorism was exposed as such in a book by an American writer, the Saudi sued her in a British court and won. Her response was to go to court in New York and seek a declaration that the British judgment was unenforceable in America. The Second Circuit has now backed her up.

So restrictive British law can not now prevent Americans writing in America from exposing British corruption. I look forward to the fireworks!

Details here.
AutoAdmit Finally in the Firing Line

We read:

"It bills itself as the world's "most prestigious college discussion board", giving a glimpse into law school admissions policies, post-graduate social networking and the hiring practices of major law firms. But the AudoAdmit site, widely used by law students for information on schools and firms, is also known as a venue for racist and sexist remarks and career-damaging rumors.

Now it's at the heart of a defamation lawsuit that legal experts say could test the anonymity of the Internet. After facing lewd comments and threats by posters, two women at Yale Law School filed a suit on June 8 in US District Court in New Haven, Connecticut, that includes subpoenas for 28 anonymous users of the site, which has generated more than seven million posts since 2004.

According to court documents, a user on the site named "STANFORDtroll" began a thread in 2005 seeking to warn Yale students about one of the women in the suit, entitled "Stupid Bitch to Enter Yale Law". Another threatened to rape and sodomise her, the documents said.

Source

I blogged on 5th about the incredible immunity this site has enjoyed so far.

Sunday, June 17, 2007

California School Sued for Banning "God"



We read:

"A Michigan public interest law firm filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the Poway Unified School District on Monday, arguing that school officials violated a math teacher's constitutional rights when they order him to remove two banners with the words "God" and "Creator" on them from his classroom walls.

The lawsuit alleges that the school district violated Westview High School teacher Bradley Johnson's freedom of speech when officials ordered him to take down the banners in January after more than 25 years of displaying them because they conveyed a religious message.

The banners, measuring approximately 7 feet long by 2 feet wide, carried the phrases: "In God We Trust," "One Nation Under God," "God Bless America," "God Shed His Grace on Thee" and "All Men Are Created Equal, They are Endowed By Their Creator," the lawsuit said.

All of which are phrases from either historical texts, like the Declaration of Independence, patriotic songs or the Pledge of Allegiance, said Robert Muise, an attorney with the Thomas More Law Center who is handling the case.

"Here you have educational banners that convey messages from our religious history," Muise said Tuesday by phone, adding that the banners were "educational" in nature and serve a clear purpose in public schools, helping teachers, like Johnson, to educate students to be better informed citizens.....

Peter Scheer, the executive director of the California First Amendment Coalition agreed, saying that the phrases were a representation of America's history, and as such, are an important aspect of a student's education. "No one in their right minds would think that to read segments or excerpts from the great founding documents of this country which include invocations of the Almighty, that that could conceivably violate some students' religious rights," Scheer said.

In addition to alleging that the district violated Johnson's California and U.S. constitutional rights by restricting his speech, the lawsuit said that this restriction "serves no educational purpose, is not reasonably related to any legitimated pedagogical concern, and conveys a government-sponsored message of disapproval of and hostility toward religion."

Johnson is asking that the district be prohibited from enforcing such "viewpoint-based" restriction on certain educational messages and that he be awarded nominal damages for the past loss of his constitutional rights, as well as have the cost of litigation, attorney fees and other expenses covered.

"This treatment of things that are religious in nature of sort as a pathogen that needs to be removed from the public sector needs to be stopped," Muise said. "We are in this for the long haul. If this is a case that needs to go all the way up the U.S. Supreme Court, we are certainly willing to do that."

Source

The 9th Circus will side with the school so this WILL need to go to SCOTUS
No Free Speech in Canada

Free speech laws exist to protect unpopular speeech or speech that elites disapprove of. There is, however no concept of that in the Union of Soviet Socialist Canada. The reverse applies: You can be put in jail for unpopular speech or speech that elites disapprove of. A current case is that of Canadian Professor Terry Tremaine.

Tremaine makes no secret of his belief that races differ in important ways. He has, for instance, put on the net statements that describe blacks as: "prone to criminality, as violent, basically as equivalent to being mentally disabled". Those are greatly condemned statements in North America today but statistical evidence in support of all of them is readily to be found in the academic literature. But facts and truth don't matter in deciding what you can say about certain legally privileged groups in Canada, of course.

But for making such possibly true statements he has just been raided by the Canadian police and faces 5 years in jail. Details here. There appears to be no allegation that he has incited violence against anybody. He appears to be in the gun merely for expressing his opinion.
An Enemy of the Press

We read:

"Angelina Jolie's true colors came out Wednesday as she promoted a film about freedom of the press and then tried to censor all her interviews.

Jolie is touting press freedom these days, playing the widow of murdered Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl in a new movie called "A Mighty Heart."

But Jolie turns out to be a mighty hypocrite when it comes to her own freedom of the press. Her lawyer required all journalists to sign a contract before talking to her, and Jolie instructed publicists at first to ban FOX News from the red carpet of her premiere.

Ironically, Wednesday night's premiere of the excellent Michael Winterbottom-directed film was meant to support an organization called Reporters Without Borders. Jolie, however, did everything she could to clamp down on the press and control it.

Source

Just another Hollywood lamebrain with arrogance to match, I guess. People whose job it is to speak words written by others often seem to have difficulty in coming up with any intelligent words of their own.

Saturday, June 16, 2007

Dittoheads Crush Leftists

We read:

"Radio station WIOD likely will remain Broward County's official channel for emergency information despite concerns it is also home to conservative talk show host Rush Limbaugh.

County commissioners said they were deluged with complaints from throughout the country Wednesday after they questioned whether to cut their ties with the station because of their dislike for Limbaugh. By the end of the day, a majority of commissioners vowed to renew WIOD's agreement next week.

Source
BBC: Must not Say Jerusalem is the Capital of Israel

I guess 3,000 years of history do not count to the BBC:

"The BBC apologized this week for referring to Jerusalem as Israel's capital, and promised not to repeat "the mistake," following a complaint by four British organizations.

Arab Media Watch, Muslim Public Affairs Committee, Friends of Al-Aksa and the Institute of Islamic Political Thought sent a joint complaint to the BBC after a presenter on its Football Focus program on March 24 mentioned that Jerusalem was Israel's capital and "historic soul."

In a letter to the complaining NGOs, Fraser Steel, head of editorial complaints at the BBC, said: "We of course accept that the international community does not recognize Jerusalem as Israel's capital, and that the BBC should not describe it as such..... "Senior managers will try to ensure, as you suggest, that the mistake is not repeated.....

Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev said in response: "Jerusalem is Israel's capital. It is the right of every sovereign state to determine which city will be its capital. If this is not accepted by everyone today, I am confident it will be in the future."

Source

And of course who cares that the Knesset (Israeli legislature) is in Jerusalem and that the Israeli seat of government is in Jerusalem?

Friday, June 15, 2007

Florida county may cancel deal with radio station because it airs Rush Limbaugh

We read:

"Rush Limbaugh has long been a thorn in the side of liberals, but now, because of him, some Democratic politicians don't even want to join with a local radio station to broadcast hurricane information.

Radio station WIOD, AM 610, has been the official channel for emergency information from Broward County government for the past year. The County Commission, all Democrats, balked at renewing the deal Tuesday, unable to stomach the station also being home to Limbaugh's talk show.....

Ken Charles, WIOD's director of AM programming, said Tuesday the station's talk show lineup has no relationship with its news coverage and that the county should focus on the benefits of teaming with the station. "It's a shame that people would let politics get in the way of saving lives in a hurricane," Charles said.

Source

Leftists desperately NEED political censorship
Female Chauvinist Sows Lose Out

We read:

"The 19th floor of a new, $100 million hotel will not be restricted to female guests, after all. A spokesperson for the JW Marriott luxury hotel said Monday both men and women will be allowed to rent rooms on what originally was planned as a women-only floor in the 340-room hotel slated to open in September.

The floor's lounge that was to be only for women also will be open to male guests, said the spokesperson, who asked not to be identified because the plans have not been finalized.

Both the rooms and the lounge still will feature amenities designed to appeal particularly to female business travelers, such as chenille throw blankets, ionic hair dryers, jewelry holders and special bath products.

Source

I personally think "women only" restrictions are fine -- as long as "men only" restrictions are fine too.
Another delusory whine about "gagging" from a Leftist

An editorial in "The Australian" again:

"Clive Hamilton calls himself an author but surely he's a comedian. How else to explain the following? Yesterday, New Matilda ran Hamilton's latest piece in which he said of The Australian: "No news organisation in Australia has done more to silence critics and independent voices." Now, here's the pay-off: this was run on the same day that The Australian published Hamilton's latest research paper. So while Hamilton was complaining that The Australian was silencing critics, The Australian was publishing Hamilton. Late last year, The Australian also published a report produced by the Australia Institute, of which he is executive director, on the subject of corporate pedophilia.....

Source

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Live-Blogging of Sports Events Prohibited??

If you can see it on TV, why can't you talk about it?

"A Louisville Courier-Journal sports reporter had his media credential revoked and was ordered to leave the press box during an NCAA baseball super-regional because of what the NCAA alleged was a violation of its policies prohibiting live Internet updates from its championship events, the Courier-Journal reports....

Courier-Journal executive editor Bennie L. Ivory challenged the NCAA's action and said the newspaper would consider an official response, reports C-J writer Rick Bozich. "It's clearly a First Amendment issue," Ivory said. "This is part of the evolution of how we present the news to our readers. It's what we did during the Orange Bowl. It's what we did during the NCAA basketball tournament. It's what we do."...

"It's a real question that we're being deprived of our right to report within the First Amendment from a public facility," said Jon L. Fleischaker, the newspaper's attorney. "Once a player hits a home run, that's a fact. It's on TV. Everybody sees it. (The NCAA) can't copyright that fact. The blog wasn't a simulcast or a recreation of the game. It was an analysis."

Source
Australian 'Beer boobs' advertisements are a boo-boo



We read:

"Beer ads starring a bikini-clad woman under the title "Hahn boobs" are under fire for offensive sexism.

The state's peak health advisory body, VicHealth, has written to the Advertising Standards Bureau asking for the ads to be shelved.

VicHealth boss Todd Harper said the treatment of women in the ads on television and the internet was appalling.

In the television advertisment promoting low carb beer Hahn Superdry, a young man turns a love heart drawn in the sand by a bikini-wearing woman into a pair of breasts before swigging from a beer bottle.

The internet site, Hahn Boobs, takes the campaign a step further.

Source

It mainly seems to be feminists behind the objections. But feminists never have liked femininity.
Yet Again a Leftist Equates Disagreement with "Gagging"

It happens in Australia too. Leftists are such emotionally fragile creatures that they just cannot cope with contrary arguments -- understandable, given how shallow their own arguments are. The editorial from "The Australian" below is a tad sarcastic:

"There is no better way to start the day than with a good chuckle. Happily, there was Robert Manne in the letters pages of The Australian yesterday to give us one. Manne was all upset about Monday's editorial: "Reality bites the psychotic Left." He objected to the idea that the Left is obsessed with issues of the 1970s. He is also interested in Iraq, and climate change, he sniffed. That's quite right: in The Age in 2003, Manne wrote about Iraq, saying suicide bombers were "brave" and could not plausibly be described as "terrorists" because they were not "wantonly" taking the lives of innocent civilians. No? Not even those who later took the lives of children and UN staff? ....

Manne's most astonishing claim is that the Left has been silenced by the Howard Government. In the foreword to a new book, Silencing Dissent, he laments the "absence of powerful scrutiny" of the current government. Is Manne unaware of the relentless coverage of the AWB scandal, to use but one example? Could there have been any more written in the nation's media, in particular this newspaper, about the Tampa, or the children overboard affair? Does he know that 120,000 new blogs are started every day?

[sarcasm on] Manne says debate is "presently under threat", which would be why people were too terrified to march in their hundreds of thousands against the war in Iraq. You hardly ever hear a word against the Government's Work Choices legislation either, do you? David Marr can never get a word in. And, if the polls are any guide, Labor is really struggling to be heard. It is way ahead in most Australian states only because . . . well, who knows? Perhaps Robert Manne can tell us. Pity we won't be able to hear through the mouth gag he is forced to wear, both hands tied behind his back to prevent him from writing books, essays, columns and, now, letters to The Australian. [end sarcasm]

Source

There is a more extended comment on this nonsense here

Nearly as amusing as the comments by Robert Manne referred to above are some comments from an Australian Leftist blogger who attracts a huge volume of comments to his posts -- the no-longer-anonymous Jeremy Sear. The Searing one also objects to the editorial that Manne objected to.

But the Searing one's main objection is that the editorial sets up a "straw man" version (false picture) of what Leftists are. So how does he deal with that? By setting up his own straw man version of what what conservatives say Leftists are! In good Leftist style he projects his own straw-man style of argument on to his opponents.

He claims that conservatives say Leftists are "baby-eating progress-denying decadent "elites" who hate "ordinary people" and love it when their homes burn down".

One can only pity such a weak mind.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

CBS News Anchor Bryant Gumbel Says He Was Right to Call Pro-Family Advocate a F***ing Idiot

We read:

"Yesterday, while filling-in for Regis Philbin on Live with Regis and Kelly, CBS News Early Show anchor Bryant Gumbel actually boasted about once calling conservative culture-critic Robert Knight "a f***ing idiot". Gumbel used the actual word at the end of a June 29, 2000 interview on CBS's The Early Show about whether active homosexuals should work as scoutmasters in the Boy Scouts. Mr. Knight, then with the Family Research Council, is now the director of the Media Research Center's Culture (MRC) and Media Institute.

After the first incident, the Media Research Center called on Mr. Gumbel to apologize. He remained silent. His employer, CBS, made the astounding claim that they did not know what Mr. Gumbel had said, although the incident was captured on videotape and live television.

Source

Imus is out and Isaiah Washington is out for abusive speech so Gumbel will go too now -- or am I missing something?
No Right to Wave Flags?

Waving flags is a way of expressing loyalty that goes back into the mists of time. And there is no legal ban on waving ANY flag in the USA. You can see the Mexican flag being waved anytime there is one of the many demonstrations by Leftists in favour of illegal immigration. And during the Vietnam war, the same types waved the flag of Communist North Vietnam plenty of times.

So on what authority are soccer fans in Salt Lake City not allowed to wave the flags of Tibet and Taiwan? It happened recently at a match between a team from the People's Republic of China and Real Salt Lake.

It is something of a tradition in soccer for fans to try to spook the opposing team in various ways and my guess is that most of the flag wavers were just supporting their team rather than being very political but the Chinese said they would walk off the field if the flags were not taken down.

So what did RSL management do? Did they say: "Sorry. We have free speech in America. There's nothing we can do about it". No way. They sent goons among the fans to stop the flag waving, confiscated flags and booted one fan off the ground.

I understand that there are now legal moves against RSL management over their illegal trampling on the rights of their fans but with courts that believe in a "living" constitution, I would not be surprised if the First Amendment took another hit over this one. Details here and here.

Update:

A real-life example below (from Australia) of the SORT of firm but courteous reply that RSL officials COULD have given to the Chinese officials.

"Foreign Minister Alexander Downer has called on China to respect Australia's democratic system following warnings from Beijing over the Dalai Lama's visit. The exiled Tibetan monk has been warmly welcomed during his 11-day tour of Australia, meeting Federal Opposition Leader Kevin Rudd yesterday and Prime Minister John Howard later this week.

China's Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang yesterday said the Dalai Lama's Australian visit could harm bilateral ties.

Mr Downer said today that Australia was not ignoring China's warning but said it had already explained its position. "We've taken note of what they've had to say," he said on Sky News. "But I've explained to the Chinese on a number of occasions in relation to this issue that in this country, the Dalai Lama is regarded as a religious figure, a significant religious figure. "And it's just not a proposition for us to refuse to give someone like the Dalai Lama a visa to visit Australia.

"China has a very different political system from Australia but I've asked the Chinese to respect the way our culture and our political system works."

Source

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Leftist Insensitivity must not be Criticized

Leftists are lightning-fast to perceive and condemn insensitivity in others. But what happens when it is the Leftist that is being insensitive?

In Australia, a Leftist university student under the guidance of Leftist professors made a "comedy" film that ridiculed disabled people. Insensitive? It would be hard to imagine anything more insensitive. So what happened?

Nothing. So two conservative professors at the university concerned wrote an article expressing their disgust. They began their article: "A time comes when you have to say: ``Enough!'', when you can no longer put up with the misanthropic and amoral trash produced under the rubric of postmodernist, post-structuralist thought.

In other words, they correctly identified Leftist amorality as the reason the disgusting film project had been approved. So what happened then? Did the university finally admit fault and apologize? Not at all. The two conservative professors have now lost their jobs for six months -- for daring to criticize Leftist trash. Details here and here

The head of the university concerned and the man behind the firings is Prof. Peter Coaldrake. You can ring him to tell him what you think of him. His cellphone is 61 418 642 375. His Office no. is 617 3864 8086 and his home no. is 617 3252 4388. The 61 in the preceding nos. is the country-code for Australia. To make an international call you may have to dial some other number first. Coaldrake's email is p.coaldrake@qut.edu.au

I am not going to post anything else here today as I want to encourage readers to use their time to make themselves heard about this. The victimized professors are very upset by the way they have been treated so need all the help they can get.

Monday, June 11, 2007

"Gangs" Incorrect in Britain

We read:

"Youths who hang around committing crime and anti-social behaviour should not be described as gangs, the Youth Justice Board said today.

Using the term to describe groups of youths was "inappropriate" and could actually make their activities worse, a major study on gangs suggested.

Instead of the phrase "gang-related" the report used the term "group-related", although it declined to coin a new definition of what constituted a gang.

Source
Colonel Baggio Replies

My post of June 6th about Army spokesman Baggio using the term "God's work" for what the troops are doing provoked an unusually large volume of comments on STACLU. For those who have missed it, Colonel Baggio himself has now also commented. I reproduce his reply below for the convenience of readers:

"Well, well, well.... I was resisting responding to this, but have succumbed to temptation and must now put a stake in it. Everybody on both the right and left sides of the fence needs to lighten up a tad here. Somewhere among what I allegedly said, what Pauline from AP noted, what the AP editors edited, and what some of you readers interpreted, the whole context of my comments has been lost and distorted.

Let me get the mea culpa out of the way - if I used the word God - I regret that I did, especially today in this world where folks hang on your every word, over-analyze it and in turn over-react. Although I'm no rookie to the Army (enlisted in the National Guard in Nov 1979; became a Regular Army Officer in April 1983) or to the media (11 years media relations experience), this is a testament that we can and should learn something every day; I've certainly been reminded to be more cautious.

That said, assuming maybe I did say "God" - it was only a figure of speech; I could have said "yeoman's work", "more than their fare share of the work", incredible work, freaking hard work - you get the point!!! I'm curious - from that passage, how does one assume I'm Christian? Didn't see Jesus or Christ in there - did ya? The last time I checked, the Jews, Christians, and Muslims worship the same God, plus many other faiths believe in a divine being.

My faith or lack of it is irrelevant. My so-called quotes came from an informal chat - albeit on the record - with AP's Pauline Jelinek in my office - I like Pauline and I don't fault her article, I'm sure she didn't intend for it to be extrapolated as a call for Christianity and probably most people didn't read it that way.

The focus of the interview was two-fold: 1. The number of troops who had deployed vs. haven't deployed and 2. An announcement by the Marine Commandant, saying how operationally focused they are and was the Army somewhat different - less operationally focused (translate: not as gung-ho).

I vehemently defended the lion's share of Soldiers, focusing on the Army's Warrior Ethos and that no matter where they work - theater or stateside - Soldiers contribute to the fight. I can relate, currently working at the Pentagon, but having spent 13 months and 17 days in Iraq (Jan 04 - Feb 05), plus multiple shorter war zone deployments in the Balkans. I made it clear that the Army was full of Warriors - every bit as tough as our sister service the Marines.

Well...now I got "that" off my chest - it at least makes me feel better. I'd normally sign off with something like "God Bless Our Troops" but I don't want to offend anyone else - so I'll say "Keep our Troops in your thoughts and wishes."

COL Dan Baggio, U.S. Army.

So the good Colonel was using "God's" as a synonym for "good". I do something similar myself on occasions even though I am an atheist. If I encounter a clergyman who really impresses me with his Christlike nature, I will often refer to him as "A true man of God".

Sunday, June 10, 2007

Marriage as Hate-Speech Case now Filed with US Supreme Court

We read:

"The Pro-Family Law Center has challenged Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and United States District Court rulings finding the terms "marriage," "natural family," and "family values" to be hate-speech. The case involves the threat of termination of employment by the City of Oakland against two of its employees who used such words on an employee bulletin board. ....

In United States District Court, Case No. CV-03-03542-VRW, the California federal courts concluded that the terms "marriage," "natural family," and "family values" could be censored in a municipal workplace as hate-speech and in the interest of "administrative efficiency." (See here). Specifically, the City of Oakland banned the use of these terms on postings made to an open bulletin board provided to employees during the same-sex marriage debate in California during 2002 through 2003.

Source

I mentioned this case previously on March 11th.
Dutch Leftists Muzzle Member who Wants to Help ex-Muslims



We read:

"Labour (PvdA) has been trying to muzzle a young PvdA member who is fighting for the rights and safety of Muslim apostates. An internal memo shows that the party fears the campaign of Ehsan Jami will cause it electoral damage and enrage Muslims.

Jami announced in May he was setting up a Committee for Ex-Muslims. The committee wants to break the taboo on lapsing from the Islamic faith. The 22 year old Jami, himself an apostate of Islam, says many Muslims do not dare to renounce Islam for fear of reprisals, including death.

Jami, who is a PvdA council member in the town of Leidschendam-Voorburg, will launch the committee officially in September with an international press conference. He says he has already had hundreds of e-mails from Muslims from throughout the world who support him. But his own PvdA is trying to muzzle him, it emerges from internal correspondence obtained by newspaper NRC Handelsblad.

Source